Why Our Meatloaf Might be our Best Kept Secret

Our Meatloaf - Best kept secret

True to our southern roots, our meatloaf might be our best-kept secret on the menu! It may not be glamorous, but one thing’s for sure: it is so good! Homemade, hand-formed, and served up with a heaping side of childhood memories, there’s just something irresistible about a great slice of meatloaf. Pull up a seat and dig in, we’re having meatloaf today!


Why We Love Meatloaf

Meatloaf tastes a lot like home, and that's all the reason we need to love it. Just like grandma used to make when the whole family would gather around the table, something about the dish embodies the true flavor of comfort and togetherness. Long-underrated, meatloaf perfectly encapsulates our love for great southern food. Popular with kids and adults of all ages, great for lunch or dinner, cold or hot, alone, on a sandwich, and even better the next day, meatloaf is always a winner.


The Beef About Meatloaf

Meatloaf became a staple of many American diets during the Great Depression. Original recipes were intended to let home cooks stretch protein scraps and use up excess root vegetables. Our modern version of the meatloaf was first recorded in an American recipe from the late 1870s. Using any cheap cuts of ground or minced meat, early chefs added salt, pepper, onions, and slices of milk and egg-soaked bread. Today, the recipe remains mostly the same, while still remaining incredibly flexible. Crackers, bread crumbs, or other starches are used to bulk up the ground meat, as well as any vegetables, providing more hearty servings for hungry bellies.


There’s a lot that goes into making a good meatloaf! At McCray’s Tavern on the Lawrenceville Square, we aim to create a moist and flavorful loaf: compact but not too dense, slathered with ketchup, and baked to a perfectly crispy crust on top. Served with mashed potatoes and green beans, it’s truly a meal your mom would make. And like all our dishes, we make it from scratch! Each day our kitchen team prepares the day’s meatloaves from freshly ground Angus beef, adding in farm-fresh ingredients and mixing it by hand before baking. Sliced and plated right before serving, it’s a full-sized portion of home-cooked comfort.



As a beloved dish, meatloaf serves as a connection to something bigger, a deeper nostalgia and long tradition in southern food. What once served Americans through hard times is now a special treat, one that often goes overlooked on our menu. Join us on the patio for meatloaf with all the fixins' for lunch or dinner throughout the week, and brunch on the weekends. We’re saving you a slice!

Easter Brunch Smyrna
22 Mar, 2024
Savor Easter desserts at McCray's Tavern Smyrna, such as New York Cheesecake and Peanut Butter Pie. Sweeten your Easter celebration at this popular Atlanta venue.
Brunch in Midtown ATL
22 Mar, 2024
Indulge in Easter treats at McCray's Tavern in Midtown! We have everything sweet and savory that will ensure your celebration is one both you and your family will never forget.
Easter Brunch for Kids at McCray's
22 Mar, 2024
Join us at McCray's Tavern in Lawrenceville for a memorable Easter celebration! Our kid-friendly brunch menu and captivating ambiance will make this a joyous day for the whole family.
East Cobb brunch Restaurant
22 Mar, 2024
Are you looking for a unique Easter celebration in East Cobb? Look no further than McCray’s Tavern! We are offering an assortment of traditional Easter brunch dishes with a zesty twist.
Atlanta Pet Friendly Restaurant
07 Mar, 2024
Discover the ultimate pet-friendly dining experience at The Baxter! Learn how we warmly welcome both you and your dog to enjoy a delicious meal together.
Sandwiches on the beltline
07 Mar, 2024
There’s no denying that one of the best parts about living in the city is tasting all of its local delicacies. If you are in Atlanta, Georgia, you don't have to search for the "best sandwiches near me", because there’s one place that has some of the most mouth-watering sandwiches around – McCray's Tavern, one of the best restaurants on Beltline Atlanta. Renowned for its unique blend of flavors and top-notch ingredients, this eatery has curated a menu that beckons sandwich lovers from all corners. Join us as we explore our signature sandwiches – a true testament to why we are the best sandwich place in town. Magic Mushroom Wrap First on our list is the Magic Mushroom Wrap, a vegetarian delight that combines fresh ingredients to create a symphony of flavors. Picture this: crisp lettuce, juicy tomato, tangy chopped pickles, and the richness of cheddar jack cheese. What takes this wrap to the next level is the buffalo-style fried mushroom, adding a bold and spicy kick. Drizzled with ranch dressing, it's a harmonious dance of textures and tastes that makes you wonder if you've stumbled upon the best sandwich place in the city. You Can Tuna- A Guitar but You Can’t Tuna Melt For those craving a unique twist on the classic tuna melt, McCray's has it "You Can Tuna- A Guitar but You Can’t Tuna Melt." A Yellowfin tuna steak takes center stage, complemented by creamy avocado, zesty red onion, and the velvety goodness of Munster cheese. The wasabi aioli adds a hint of heat, bringing a burst of flavor to every bite. Sandwich enthusiasts seeking the best sandwiches near me need not look further – this tuna melt is a masterpiece on multi-grain bread. The Godfather Grinder Prepare your taste buds for an offer they can't refuse – The Godfather Grinder. This sandwich is a carnivore's dream, featuring Genoa salami, hot coppa, mortadella, pepperoni, and aged provolone. Topped with crisp lettuce, juicy tomato, roasted garlic aioli, pickled cherry peppers, and a drizzle of oil and vinegar. Undisputedly one of the best sandwiches on the Beltline. The Cubano Missile Crisis The Cubano Missile Crisis is a Cuban-inspired sensation made of Mojo-roasted pork, smoked ham, and Swiss cheese form the heart of this sandwich. House pickles, house deli mustard, and the perfect Cuban bread bring authenticity to every bite. If you're on a quest for the best sandwiches near me, this Cubano masterpiece is a must-try. The Marty McFly Whether you prefer it grilled or fried, The Marty McFly is a nod to classic American flavors with a twist. Featuring buffalo chicken panini, prevalence, bacon, crisp lettuce, and your choice of ranch or blue cheese, this sandwich is a time-traveling delight. The Rocket Manwhich Closing our sandwich tour is the popular Rocket Manwhich. This dish pays homage to classic Southern comfort food. A sloppy joe, paired with house pickles, fried Vidalia onion, and peppery rocket arugula, all nestled within a soft brioche bun. It's messy, it's flavorful, and it's a reminder that sometimes the best sandwiches near me are the ones that embrace the joy of indulgence. Experience The Best Sandwich Place on the Beltline Today Discover the ultimate sandwich experience on the Beltline at McCray's Tavern today. Our signature sandwiches showcase culinary innovation and an unwavering dedication to excellence. Whether you're on the hunt for the top sandwich spot or a premier Beltline bar, your quest ends here. Dive into the flavorful adventure of our Magic Mushroom Wrap, savor the robustness of The Godfather Grinder, or take a nostalgic trip with The Marty McFly. Let us reshape your idea of the ideal sandwich.
St. Patricks-day in Smyrna
05 Mar, 2024
St. Patrick’s Day is coming and that means it’s time for good food and great drinks. Join us at McCray’s Tavern for a wonderful holiday menu with Irish flair!
Flavors of Ireland at McCray's
05 Mar, 2024
Wondering what to do for St. Patrick’s Day? Come to McCray’s for some fantastic Irish meals and cold drinks, and to celebrate with friends and family!
St Patricks Day Celebration Lawrenceville
05 Mar, 2024
St. Patrick’s Day is around the corner, and that means it’s time to celebrate! Come to McCray’s Tavern and enjoy delicious options from our holiday menu!
St. Patrick's Day at McCray's Tavern
05 Mar, 2024
Looking for a place to dine this St. Patrick’s Day? Head to McCray’s Tavern for delicious Irish specialties and a great dining experience!
More Posts
Share by: